Written by: Sandeep Ravindran, Ph.D. | Issue # 68 | 2017
- A new study finds that consuming butter induces a significantly greater increase in LDL cholesterol compared with cheese, and the effects are particularly pronounced in participants with high baseline LDL cholesterol.
- The results suggest that the cheese food matrix helps attenuate some of the cardiometabolic effects of consuming saturated fats.
- The new study adds to the evidence that the effects of dietary saturated fats on cardiovascular disease risk may depend on the food source.
Saturated fatty acids (SFAs) have long been considered detrimental to cardiovascular health, with dietary guidelines advocating for a restriction of dietary SFAs to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) . However, increased consumption of SFAs may not always be associated with increased CVD risk, and the effects of SFAs on CVD risk may instead depend on the food source [2-5].
A new randomized control trial conducted by Professor Benoit Lamarche of Université Laval compared the cardiometabolic effects of consuming saturated fats in butter compared with consuming saturated fats in cheese . “The basis of this project was the controversy about the effects of saturated fats on cardiovascular disease,” says Didier Brassard, a graduate student in Lamarche’s laboratory and the first author of the new study. “So the idea was to compare two different food sources of saturated fats, which in our project was butter compared with cheese, as well as to compare that with other nutrients,” he says. In addition to cheese and butter, the researchers also gave participants diets rich in monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs), polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs), and carbohydrates.
Brassard and his colleagues compared the effects of these five diets on a number of cardiometabolic risk factors, including blood lipid concentrations and blood pressure. “One of the most interesting findings of this paper was that butter induces a significantly greater increase in LDL cholesterol than cheese,” says Brassard. “So saturated fat in cheese and saturated fat in butter do not behave the same when they are digested,” he says. “A new thing was that the effects occurred especially among the people who had a greater concentration of LDL cholesterol to start with,” says Brassard.
HDL cholesterol concentrations were similar after the cheese and butter diets, although they were significantly higher than after the carbohydrate diet. There was no significant difference between the effects of the diets on inflammation markers, blood pressure, and insulin-glucose homeostasis.
The differences in the effects of butter and cheese are consistent with previous studies. “Other randomized control trials in the past have shown that saturated fats in butter and cheese behave differently when they are eaten in equal amounts,” says Brassard. In addition, a meta-analysis showed that for a similar intake of saturated fats and ratio of SFAs to PUFAs, the consumption of hard cheese significantly reduced LDL cholesterol and HDL cholesterol compared with butter .
The researchers hypothesized that the cheese food matrix was responsible for the attenuation of the cardiometabolic effects associated with the consumption of SFAs. Previous studies suggested that the beneficial effects of certain dairy products on CVD risk appear to be mediated by the dairy matrix . “There are also randomized control trials that supported the idea that the food source and the food matrix may influence the effect of saturated fats on health,” says Brassard .
The researchers tried to estimate the effect of the cheese matrix on cholesterol. “The whole idea was just to look at how much saturated fat was in the diet, and based on previously published equations, compare the predicted effect on LDL versus what was observed,” says Brassard . “What was predicted and the observed concentration were different,” he says. “What we can say is that there are nutrients in cheese that are reducing the overall effect of saturated fats so that they do not induce as much change in blood lipids compared with butter,” says Brassard.
“What we show in this paper is that the food matrix matters, as different foods with the same nutrients can have different effects on cardiometabolic risk factors, mainly blood lipids and LDL cholesterol,” says Brassard. “So it’s important to look beyond nutrients and think in terms of foods,” he says.
It’s still unclear what components of the food matrix may be responsible for influencing CVD risk. “This is pretty elusive at the moment,” says Brassard. Researchers have hypothesized that the effects of the cheese matrix may be mediated by calcium, or minerals, or the presence of bacteria. “There are a couple of hypotheses, but nothing is clear at the moment,” says Brassard. A recent study by Lamarche’s lab showed that the cheese matrix modulates the effects of dairy fat on lipid metabolism . “They showed that the cheese matrix influences digestion,” says Brassard. “So this is another possibility for why the cheese matrix induces a different response than the butter matrix,” he says.
Lamarche, Brassard and their colleagues plan to continue studying the effects of the food matrix. Another study of theirs looks at the effects of the food matrix on cholesterol efflux capacity, a marker of HDL functionality . “We observed a food matrix effect, as butter induces a greater change in cholesterol efflux capacity than cheese,” says Brassard. “That study also supports the notion that the food matrix influences lipid metabolism,” he says.
These studies add to the growing evidence that the food source of saturated fats is important in assessing their health impacts. “From a public health perspective, it’s important to look beyond nutrients and think in terms of food, because different foods have different effects, and this is another example of that,” says Brassard.
1. Van Horn L., Carson J.A., Appel L.J., Burke L.E., Economos C., Karmally W., Lancaster K., Lichtenstein A.H., Johnson R.K., Thomas R.J., Vos M., Wylie-Rosett J., Kris-Etherton P., American Heart Association Nutrition Committee of the Council on Lifestyle and Cardiometabolic Health, Council on Cardiovascular Disease in the Young, Council on Cardiovascular and Stroke Nursing, Council on Clinical Cardiology, Stroke Council. Recommended Dietary Pattern to Achieve Adherence to the American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology (AHA/ACC) Guidelines: A Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association. Circulation. 2016 Nov 29;134(22):e505-e529.
2. de Souza R.J., Mente A., Maroleanu A., Cozma A.I., Ha V., Kishibe T., Uleryk E., Budylowski P., Schünemann H., Beyene J., Anand S.S. Intake of saturated and trans unsaturated fatty acids and risk of all cause mortality, cardiovascular disease, and type 2 diabetes: systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies. BMJ. 2015 Aug 11;351:h3978.
3. Chowdhury R., Warnakula S., Kunutsor S., Crowe F., Ward H.A., Johnson L., Franco O.H., Butterworth A.S., Forouhi N.G., Thompson S.G., Khaw K.T., Mozaffarian D., Danesh J., Di Angelantonio E. Association of dietary, circulating, and supplement fatty acids with coronary risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Intern Med. 2014 Mar 18;160(6):398-406.
4. de Oliveira Otto M.C., Mozaffarian D., Kromhout D., Bertoni A.G., Sibley C.T., Jacobs D.R. Jr, Nettleton J.A. Dietary intake of saturated fat by food source and incident cardiovascular disease: the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012 Aug;96(2):397-404.
5. de Goede J., Geleijnse J.M., Ding E.L., Soedamah-Muthu S.S. Effect of cheese consumption on blood lipids: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Nutr Rev. 2015 May;73(5): 259-75.
6. Brassard D., Tessier-Grenier M., Allaire J., Rajendiran E., She Y., Ramprasath V., Gigleux I., Talbot D., Levy E., Tremblay A., Jones P.J., Couture P., Lamarche B. Comparison of the impact of SFAs from cheese and butter on cardiometabolic risk factors: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 2017 Apr;105(4):800-809.
7. Thorning T.K., Bertram H.C., Bonjour J.P., de Groot L., Dupont D., Feeney E., Ipsen R., Lecerf J.M., Mackie A., McKinley M.C., Michalski M.C., Rémond D., Risérus U., Soedamah-Muthu S.S., Tholstrup T., Weaver C., Astrup A., Givens I. Whole dairy matrix or single nutrients in assessment of health effects: current evidence and knowledge gaps. Am J Clin Nutr. 2017 May;105(5):1033-1045.
8. Mensink R.P., Zock P.L., Kester A.D., Katan M.B. Effects of dietary fatty acids and carbohydrates on the ratio of serum total to HDL cholesterol and on serum lipids and apolipoproteins: a meta-analysis of 60 controlled trials. Am J Clin Nutr. 2003 May;77(5): 1146-55.
9. Drouin-Chartier J., Tremblay A.J., Maltais-Giguère J., Charest A., Guinot L., Rioux L., Labrie S., Britten M., Lamarche B., Turgeon S.L., Couture P. Differential impact of the cheese matrix on the postprandial lipid response: a randomized, crossover, controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 2017 Oct; pii: ajcn165027.